Schedule Online
August 16, 2025

What Are the Top 3 Common Causes of Water Heater Failure?

There’s nothing like an unexpected cold shower to remind you just how important your water heater really is. If you’ve ever dealt with a failing unit, you already know the stress it can cause—from water damage to throwing off your whole day. 

JG Water Heaters, Filtration and Plumbing understands how frustrating water heater breakdowns can be, especially when they seem to come out of nowhere. But here’s the truth: most water heater problems don’t just happen overnight. They usually start small and build up over time. 

Knowing the causes of the most common water heater problems can help you spot early warning signs, make informed decisions, and avoid costly emergency water heater repairs. Our pros explain the top 3 most common reasons residential water heaters fail, and what you can do about them.

1. Sediment Buildup Inside the Tank

Over time, minerals in your water settle at the bottom of your hot water heater tank. These minerals, mostly calcium and magnesium, harden into sediment. As the layer thickens, it creates a barrier between the burner (for gas water heaters) or heating element (for electric water heaters) and the water. This forces your unit to work harder, leading to overheating, inefficiency, and eventually system failure.

Warning signs include:

  • Rumbling or popping noises from the tank
  • Hot water that runs out quickly
  • Increased energy bills
  • Water that appears rusty or discolored

Sediment diminishes efficient operation and can cause the tank to overheat and crack or even shorten the life of your unit. In worst-case scenarios, it can lead to leaks or full tank failure that cause significant water damage to your home.

Prevention & Solutions

Annual flushing of your water heater tank can remove sediment, restore energy efficiency, lower energy bills, and keep your system running smoothly. In the San Diego area, hard water is common; installing reliable solutions like a whole-house water filtration or softening system can also reduce mineral buildup. 

If your water heater is already showing signs of distress or you notice the water heater leaking, a hot water heater repair professional can assess the damage and recommend next steps.

2. Corrosion and Rust

Water heaters are made of metal, and metal + water = corrosion. While tanks are lined to resist rust, over time that lining can wear down, especially if the anode rod (a part designed to prevent corrosion) deteriorates. Once corrosion sets in, it can eat through the tank, piping, and internal components.

Warning signs include:

  • Rusty water when using hot taps
  • Corrosion around pipe fittings or at the base of the tank
  • Leaks or drips near the tank
  • Foul-smelling or metallic-tasting hot water

Once corrosion begins inside a tank, it’s usually a sign the unit is nearing the end of its life. Rust weakens the structural integrity of the water heater and can lead to sudden leaks or even flooding. It’s not something that can be repaired once it’s widespread; at that point, a new water heater installation is the only option.

How to Prevent Corrosion and Rust

Regular maintenance, inspections, and replacing the anode rod every 3–5 years can help prevent corrosion. If your system is over 8 years old or showing signs of rust, it may be time to explore a replacement. 

The experienced team at JG Water Heaters, Filtration and Plumbing provides water heater services to maintain your system. During service, we can evaluate your system honestly and help you decide whether hot water heater repair or replacement is the best path forward.

3. Worn-Out or Faulty Components

Water heaters contain many components, like thermostats, heating elements, gas burners, valves, sensors. Just like with any mechanical system, these parts can wear out over time. A single failed component can cause everything from a complete lack of hot water to inconsistent temperatures or system shutdown.

Warning signs include:

  • No hot water at all
  • Water that’s too hot or not hot enough
  • Pilot light keeps going out
  • Thermostat seems unresponsive
  • Strange noises or smells

Often, a failing component is a simple fix, but if ignored, it can strain the entire system and lead to bigger failures. This is why many homeowners searching for water heater repair near me are surprised to learn that a small repair could’ve been done long before the issue became critical.

Catch the Problem Early

Routine maintenance can catch problems before they escalate. If you’re experiencing any signs of trouble, don’t wait until your water heater quits altogether. Quick San Diego water heater repair from a trusted local company like JG Water Heaters, Filtration and Plumbing can save you from bigger headaches (and bigger bills) later.

What to Do If You Suspect a Problem

If you’re noticing any of the warning signs we mentioned, it’s time to take action. Ignoring the issue could lead to more expensive repairs, higher energy bills, or even water damage.

Here’s what you can do:

  1. Turn off the power or gas supply to your water heater if you suspect a serious problem like a leak or overheating.

  2. Check for obvious signs like pooling water, rust, or unusual sounds.

  3. Contact a professional for inspection. A licensed technician from JG Water Heaters, Filtration and Plumbing can quickly diagnose the problem and recommend the right repair—or replacement if necessary.

Fast, Honest Help When You Need It Most

We know that when you’re searching for San Diego water heater repair, you’re probably not in the mood to wait. JG Water Heaters, Filtration and Plumbing prioritizes fast, honest service—often with same-day availability. Our team works with all major brands of tank and tankless water heaters, so no matter the issue, we have the solution.

We’re not a giant call center. When you call us, you’re getting real help from a real person who genuinely wants to solve your problem.

Need Water Heater Repair in San Diego? Let’s Make That Problem Go Away.

You wouldn’t wait for your car engine to fail before getting an oil change, right? Your water heater needs regular checkups, too, so it continues to perform safely and efficiently. Unfortunately, many homeowners don’t realize there’s a problem until they’re stuck without hot water, or worse, dealing with water damage.

The good news? Most major issues are preventable with annual maintenance and timely hot water heater repairs.

Don’t let a water heater issue linger. The sooner you act, the easier—and more affordable—the solution usually is. Call JG Water Heaters, Filtration and Plumbing for reliable, no-pressure guidance and same-day San Diego water heater repair whenever possible.

You deserve hot water you can count on. We’re here to make sure you have it.